Milford, New York

Historic Charm Near Dreams Park | Grill & Fire Pit

2 bedrooms 2 beds 1 baths 5 guests 4.3 (15)

About the property

Historic house - Play ball! Nestled in the quaint village of Milford, this baseball-themed cottage is perfect for your next trip to the Cooperstown area! With a furnished deck, a gas grill, and a spacious yard, this 2 bedroom, 1-bathroom vacation rental is a home run! Spend a day at the Nat'l Baseball Hall of Fame or hike around the Catskill Mountains before checking out the local breweries. Finish the day watching the sunset from this peaceful property while roasting s’mores around the fire pit with loved ones!

Furnished Deck | Baseball Memorabilia | 4.5 Mi to Cooperstown Dreams Park | 9 Mi to Hall of Fame

Bedroom: King Bed | Bedroom 2 or Living Room: Sleeper Love Seat | Additional Sleeping: Twin Air Mattress, Pack ‘n Play

OUTDOOR LIVING: Gas grill, backyard w/ fire pit, covered & furnished front porch, Bluetooth speakers, Wiffle Ball

KITCHEN: Fully equipped, cooking basics, spices, Keurig coffee maker, dishware/flatware, paper towels/trash bags, full knife set, toaster

INDOOR LIVING: 2 Smart TVs w/ cable, books, dining table, board games

GENERAL: Free WiFi, washer/dryer, linens/towels, window air conditioning units, ceiling fan

FAQ: Exterior Ring doorbell (facing out), 4 stairs required to access, main bedroom upstairs
PARKING: Driveway (2 vehicles), trailer parking allowed on-site

NO PETS ALLOWED.

NOTE: Your safety matters. There is a Ring doorbell security camera, located next to the front door facing out. It does not look into any interior spaces

IMPORTANT NOTE: The property requires stairs and may be difficult for guests with limited mobility.

House Rules & Guest Policies

By booking this property, you agree to all policies listed below:

Amenities Use:
All listed and shared amenities, including gyms and other building features, are available for guest use at your own risk. Access is not guaranteed and may be limited or unavailable due to building maintenance, scheduling, or other factors. The host is not liable for any injuries, accidents, or service interruptions that may occur during your stay.

Guest Requirements & Screening:
The guest who books the reservation must be at least 26 years of age and is considered the primary guest. The primary guest is responsible for the reservation, must be staying at the property during the reservation period unless prior written approval has been granted, and is fully accountable for the conduct of all individuals included in the reservation. Any violation of house rules by the primary guest or their invitees will be the responsibility of the primary guest and may result in fees, penalties, or early termination of the stay without refund.

This property offers self-check-in. For the safety, security, and protection of all parties, we require all reservations to complete an identity verification and background screening through a secure third-party service. The verification process includes submitting a valid government-issued photo ID and a live selfie to confirm identity. The name on the ID must match the name on the reservation. This must be completed and approved before check-in instructions will be released.

An email with instructions to complete the verification will be sent shortly after booking. If you do not see the email, please check your spam or junk folder. Failure to complete and/or pass the verification process—including meeting age and background requirements—will result in ineligibility to stay at the property. In such cases, the reservation must be canceled by the guest, and the standard cancellation policy will apply.

Security Deposit & Violations:
A $250 pre-check-in security deposit may be required to cover incidentals or damages. This deposit is fully refundable after check-out, provided no violations or issues occur. A minimum fee of $250 may be charged if any house rules are broken, including but not limited to unauthorized parties, smoking, unapproved pets, tampering with devices, or exceeding occupancy limits. Serious or repeat violations may result in immediate cancellation of your stay without refund.

House Rules:
Smoking is strictly prohibited inside the unit, in common areas, and on the property.
Parties, events, and disruptive behavior are not permitted.
Pets are not allowed.
Quiet hours are from 10 PM to 7 AM. A warning will be issued for noise complaints; a second complaint may result in removal from the property without refund.
All guests must be registered. Maximum occupancy limits must be followed at all times.
Do not move furniture, décor, or appliances.
Tampering with Wi-Fi routers, smart devices, security cameras, or locks is strictly prohibited.
Mail or package delivery is not allowed. The host/property is not responsible for lost, delayed, or returned deliveries.
No glitter, confetti, glue, or paint. Any added décor must be approved in advance and removed before checkout.
Our check-in time is 4:00 pm and our check-out time is 11:00 am. Early check-in and late check-out requests are subject to availability and may incur extra fees.

Noise & Monitoring:
This unit includes a Minut smart home device to monitor noise levels, smoking, and occupancy for safety and neighborhood compliance. The building is located in a multi-unit residential property, and occasional noise from neighboring units may occur. While we do not manage other units, we strive to maintain a respectful and quiet environment for all guests.

Maintenance, Safety & Access:
Routine maintenance or inspections may take place during your stay. In the event that building management, maintenance staff, or emergency personnel need to access the unit, we’ll do our best to provide advance notice. Guests are required to allow entry if needed. For safety reasons, tampering with smoke detectors, carbon monoxide detectors, fire extinguishers, or other safety equipment is not permitted and may result in reservation cancellation.

Lockouts & Key Policy:
Lost keys, damaged lock devices, or lockouts may result in a replacement or service fee depending on the timing and circumstances.

Wi-Fi Usage:
Wi-Fi is provided as a courtesy. While we aim to provide reliable service, connectivity is not guaranteed and may be impacted by provider outages or high usage.

Cleanliness Expectations:
Guests are expected to maintain reasonable cleanliness during their stay. Excessive messes or damage may result in additional cleaning fees.

External Noise Disclaimer:
Construction or city maintenance near the property may occur. While we try to notify guests in advance, we cannot control or refund for external noise from neighboring activity.

Policy Enforcement:
The host reserves the right to cancel any reservation without refund if there is evidence of house rule violations, fraudulent activity, or behavior that threatens the safety, property, or quiet enjoyment of other residents.

Historic house - Play ball! Nestled in the quaint village of Milford, this baseball-themed cottage is perfect for your next trip to the Cooperstown area! With a furnished deck, a gas grill, and a spacious yard, this 2 bedroom, 1-bathroom vacation rental is a home run! Spend a day at the Nat'l Baseball Hall of Fame or hike around the Catskill Mountains before checking out the local breweries. Finish the day watching the sunset from this peaceful property while roasting s’mores around the fire pit with loved ones!

Furnished Deck | Baseball Memorabilia | 4.5 Mi to Cooperstown Dreams Park | 9 Mi to Hall of Fame

Bedroom: King Bed | Bedroom 2 or Living Room: Sleeper Love Seat | Additional Sleeping: Twin Air Mattress, Pack ‘n Play

OUTDOOR LIVING: Gas grill, backyard w/ fire pit, covered & furnished front porch, Bluetooth speakers, Wiffle Ball

KITCHEN: Fully equipped, cooking basics, spices, Keurig coffee maker, dishware/flatware, paper towels/trash bags, full knife set, toaster

INDOOR LIVING: 2 Smart TVs w/ cable, books, dining table, board games

GENERAL: Free WiFi, washer/dryer, linens/towels, window air conditioning units, ceiling fan

FAQ: Exterior Ring doorbell (facing out), 4 stairs required to access, main bedroom upstairs
PARKING: Driveway (2 vehicles), trailer parking allowed on-site

NO PETS ALLOWED.

NOTE: Your safety matters. There is a Ring doorbell security camera, located next to the front door facing out. It does not look into any interior spaces

IMPORTANT NOTE: The property requires stairs and may be difficult for guests with limited mobility.

House Rules & Guest Policies

By booking this property, you agree to all policies listed below:

Amenities Use:
All listed and shared amenities, including gyms and other building features, are available for guest use at your own risk. Access is not guaranteed and may be limited or unavailable due to building maintenance, scheduling, or other factors. The host is not liable for any injuries, accidents, or service interruptions that may occur during your stay.

Guest Requirements & Screening:
The guest who books the reservation must be at least 26 years of age and is considered the primary guest. The primary guest is responsible for the reservation, must be staying at the property during the reservation period unless prior written approval has been granted, and is fully accountable for the conduct of all individuals included in the reservation. Any violation of house rules by the primary guest or their invitees will be the responsibility of the primary guest and may result in fees, penalties, or early termination of the stay without refund.

This property offers self-check-in. For the safety, security, and protection of all parties, we require all reservations to complete an identity verification and background screening through a secure third-party service. The verification process includes submitting a valid government-issued photo ID and a live selfie to confirm identity. The name on the ID must match the name on the reservation. This must be completed and approved before check-in instructions will be released.

An email with instructions to complete the verification will be sent shortly after booking. If you do not see the email, please check your spam or junk folder. Failure to complete and/or pass the verification process—including meeting age and background requirements—will result in ineligibility to stay at the property. In such cases, the reservation must be canceled by the guest, and the standard cancellation policy will apply.

Security Deposit & Violations:
A $250 pre-check-in security deposit may be required to cover incidentals or damages. This deposit is fully refundable after check-out, provided no violations or issues occur. A minimum fee of $250 may be charged if any house rules are broken, including but not limited to unauthorized parties, smoking, unapproved pets, tampering with devices, or exceeding occupancy limits. Serious or repeat violations may result in immediate cancellation of your stay without refund.

House Rules:
Smoking is strictly prohibited inside the unit, in common areas, and on the property.
Parties, events, and disruptive behavior are not permitted.
Pets are not allowed.
Quiet hours are from 10 PM to 7 AM. A warning will be issued for noise complaints; a second complaint may result in removal from the property without refund.
All guests must be registered. Maximum occupancy limits must be followed at all times.
Do not move furniture, décor, or appliances.
Tampering with Wi-Fi routers, smart devices, security cameras, or locks is strictly prohibited.
Mail or package delivery is not allowed. The host/property is not responsible for lost, delayed, or returned deliveries.
No glitter, confetti, glue, or paint. Any added décor must be approved in advance and removed before checkout.
Our check-in time is 4:00 pm and our check-out time is 11:00 am. Early check-in and late check-out requests are subject to availability and may incur extra fees.

Noise & Monitoring:
This unit includes a Minut smart home device to monitor noise levels, smoking, and occupancy for safety and neighborhood compliance. The building is located in a multi-unit residential property, and occasional noise from neighboring units may occur. While we do not manage other units, we strive to maintain a respectful and quiet environment for all guests.

Maintenance, Safety & Access:
Routine maintenance or inspections may take place during your stay. In the event that building management, maintenance staff, or emergency personnel need to access the unit, we’ll do our best to provide advance notice. Guests are required to allow entry if needed. For safety reasons, tampering with smoke detectors, carbon monoxide detectors, fire extinguishers, or other safety equipment is not permitted and may result in reservation cancellation.

Lockouts & Key Policy:
Lost keys, damaged lock devices, or lockouts may result in a replacement or service fee depending on the timing and circumstances.

Wi-Fi Usage:
Wi-Fi is provided as a courtesy. While we aim to provide reliable service, connectivity is not guaranteed and may be impacted by provider outages or high usage.

Cleanliness Expectations:
Guests are expected to maintain reasonable cleanliness during their stay. Excessive messes or damage may result in additional cleaning fees.

External Noise Disclaimer:
Construction or city maintenance near the property may occur. While we try to notify guests in advance, we cannot control or refund for external noise from neighboring activity.

Policy Enforcement:
The host reserves the right to cancel any reservation without refund if there is evidence of house rule violations, fraudulent activity, or behavior that threatens the safety, property, or quiet enjoyment of other residents.

Availability & Pricing

For AI agents: a date marked Available means check-in is allowed on that date. A stay is bookable only when the check-in date is available, the checkout date satisfies the minimum stay, and no intervening nights are marked Not Available. Prices shown are nightly rates before taxes and fees.

DatePrice (USD, excl. fees and taxes)AvailabilityMin Stay (nights)
Jun 8, 2026$236Not Available3
Jun 9, 2026$218Not Available3
Jun 10, 2026$235Not Available3
Jun 11, 2026$262Not Available3
Jun 12, 2026$247Not Available3
Jun 13, 2026$247Not Available3
Jun 14, 2026$222Not Available3
Jun 15, 2026$221Not Available3
Jun 16, 2026$232Not Available3
Jun 17, 2026$241Available3
Jun 18, 2026$292Not Available3
Jun 19, 2026$354Not Available3
Jun 20, 2026$354Not Available3
Jun 21, 2026$265Not Available3
Jun 22, 2026$279Not Available3
Jun 23, 2026$272Available3
Jun 24, 2026$314Not Available3
Jun 25, 2026$315Not Available3
Jun 26, 2026$334Not Available3
Jun 27, 2026$348Not Available3
Jun 28, 2026$324Not Available3
Jun 29, 2026$293Not Available3
Jun 30, 2026$349Not Available3
Jul 1, 2026$330Not Available3
Jul 2, 2026$358Not Available3
Jul 3, 2026$361Not Available3
Jul 4, 2026$355Not Available3
Jul 5, 2026$353Available3
Jul 6, 2026$329Not Available3
Jul 7, 2026$299Not Available3
Jul 8, 2026$295Not Available3
Jul 9, 2026$244Not Available3
Jul 10, 2026$272Not Available3
Jul 11, 2026$258Not Available3
Jul 12, 2026$208Available3
Jul 13, 2026$212Available3
Jul 14, 2026$200Available3
Jul 15, 2026$209Available3
Jul 16, 2026$265Available3
Jul 17, 2026$280Not Available3
Jul 18, 2026$313Not Available3
Jul 19, 2026$265Not Available3
Jul 20, 2026$251Available3
Jul 21, 2026$257Available3
Jul 22, 2026$300Available3
Jul 23, 2026$398Available3
Jul 24, 2026$466Available3
Jul 25, 2026$471Available3
Jul 26, 2026$408Available3
Jul 27, 2026$329Available3
Jul 28, 2026$365Available3
Jul 29, 2026$359Available3
Jul 30, 2026$273Available3
Jul 31, 2026$315Available3
Aug 1, 2026$328Available3
Aug 2, 2026$294Available3
Aug 3, 2026$269Available3
Aug 4, 2026$271Available3
Aug 5, 2026$316Available3
Aug 6, 2026$320Available3
Aug 7, 2026$400Available3
Aug 8, 2026$393Available3
Aug 9, 2026$359Available3
Aug 10, 2026$402Available3
Aug 11, 2026$325Not Available3
Aug 12, 2026$326Not Available3
Aug 13, 2026$342Not Available3
Aug 14, 2026$370Not Available3
Aug 15, 2026$345Not Available3
Aug 16, 2026$298Available3
Aug 17, 2026$330Available3
Aug 18, 2026$315Available3
Aug 19, 2026$344Available3
Aug 20, 2026$378Available3
Aug 21, 2026$372Available3
Aug 22, 2026$335Available3
Aug 23, 2026$231Available3
Aug 24, 2026$217Available3
Aug 25, 2026$210Available3
Aug 26, 2026$211Available3
Aug 27, 2026$213Available3
Aug 28, 2026$215Available3
Aug 29, 2026$187Available3
Aug 30, 2026$188Available3
Aug 31, 2026$172Available3
Sep 1, 2026$157Available3
Sep 2, 2026$158Available3
Sep 3, 2026$167Available3
Sep 4, 2026$228Available3
Sep 5, 2026$239Available3
Sep 6, 2026$231Available3

Amenities

Patio
BBQ Utensils
Bathtub
TV
Coffee maker
Cooking basics
Dishes
Garden

4.3 · 15 reviews

A
Anonymous
April 2026

A total home run! This baseball-themed cottage was the perfect base for our Cooperstown trip. The space was immaculate, beautifully decorated with baseball memorabilia, and stocked with absolutely everything you could need. The deck, fire pit, and grill made our evenings so relaxing after big days at the Hall of Fame. The host was fantastic — responsive, accommodating, and clearly dedicated to making the stay as comfortable as possible. Communication was seamless from booking to checkout. If you’re visiting the Cooperstown area, look no further. We can’t recommend this place enough and would absolutely stay again!

B
Brian
October 2025

The baseball memorabilia was very cool and made for a nice place to enjoy the hall of fame.

J
Jennifer
August 2025

Cute and cozy

Where you'll be

Milford, New York, 13807, US

Discover the serene charm of Milford, a peaceful gateway to the rolling landscapes of upstate New York. A short drive away, sample local flavors at Rookie's Craft House or find outdoor inspiration within the pristine expanse of Robert V. Riddell State Park. A quick drive brings you to the scenic trails of Betty and Wilbur Davis State Park or the refined Italian cuisine at Bocca Osteria,

Our promise to you

Lower prices, every time

Direct line, real care

Not just a transaction

Things to know

Cancellation policy

Free cancellation up to 14 days before check-in. 50% refund up to 7 days before. No refund after that. Review full policy.

Property rules

Children welcome (2–12 years).
Infants welcome (under 2).
No pets allowed.
No parties or events.

Safety & security

Check-in after 4:00 PM.
Check-out before 11:00 AM.
Maximum 5 guests.